Hello! I ask everyone reading this to express their opinion or at least read it. A person is "good" when his environment is of the opposite type of people, because "out of the thorns come roses, out of the roses thorns". When we suffer, we think, when we are faced with trials, we become more tolerant of the "good" way and we receive lessons, when we receive evil, we become inclined to give good, etc. Man is "bad" when his environment is NOT his. presupposed to chances on which to build morality and "human traits". There is no realized opportunity to make sense of all the "values" and to know how to be "good". Everything depends on the environment we are in! Some are lucky to be unhappy, others are not. But are they guilty? For a person to be good, the people around him must be bad and vice versa. If we all found boundaries, then there would simply be no good people! The seven deadly sins are greed, laziness, lust, anger, envy, greed, and pride. We do not realize but more or less allow them systematically. Everything we don't have gives us things that few have. But should we all be "losers" in the eyes of others? If you are white, you are black on Earth, if you are black here you are white? !! There are many people who think they are good, but they are not. The human mind has no limits and possibilities and there may be people who do not think evil of someone, but they also commit daily small sins. Everything given on Earth can produce sin depending on its use. Everything we are given is evil. Beauty leads to vanity, luxury to greed, arrogance, pride and even sometimes to others. The chance for power collects the most "points". In order to have good, there must be evil. But the good must be punished with misfortune and vice versa. Why should we be good? What is the logic? How many thoughts are there in this life? But why is all this necessary? What is the purpose of "almighty God"? !!
Answers 14
"What is the logic of being here?" - no logic! Roughly speaking, we are here because 9 months before our birthday, our parents indulged in their animal passions and hardly thought about "logic" at that moment. You read a lot of philosophies, but it's not bad to move on to something more modern than the Old Testament of the Bible. Catch read at least the New, besides there are Kant, Rousseau, Dante, Hesse, Dostoevsky ... choose some there. I will still comment on two of the things you found @ Everything depends on the environment we are in! Some are lucky to be unhappy, others are not. But are they guilty? Nothing touches the environment we are in, because everyone is a cosmos in itself. Read The Little Prince. There is no such thing as "luck". Man forges his own destiny. The question of guilt doesn't matter, when we cannot change the circumstances and it is not a crime within the meaning of the Law. Man is to blame or innocent, who, as you can see - no one is to blame for ourselves, the people who are here and now, our happiness and unhappiness. @ A person is "bad" when his environment has NOT presupposed him to chances to build morality and "human traits". I don't think so. The environment and genes only partially shape us, from ourselves, if you will - from our soul, from our inner mind will depend on what we will be. Man, even in the Bible, is endowed with FREE WILL, don't forget. The concept of "morality" is subjective and is determined by our culture. In some Muslim countries, you will be stoned to death because you looked at and "seduced" a boy or went out without a veil. You will definitely be "immoral" in the relevant context, but in the developed world it would not be immoral, but normal. On the other hand, "good" and "bad" are common human understandings, and definitely everyone will define the stoning of an innocent girl as "bad" and the perpetrators as "bad." But here you will not meet many fans of philosophy, catch and spend your vacation reading real philosophers
Well ... for starters I'm an atheist and I can't say what the "almighty god" is up to. But I will express my opinion. I do not agree with your opinion - those surrounded by bad people are good, those surrounded by good people are bad. "Some are lucky to be unhappy, others are not." - What's good about being unhappy? Where is the luck here? And so on ... There is no person who is completely good or completely bad. And what will take precedence over the other depends entirely on this person and his experiences. People have a choice, but they don't always realize it. And the environment is really important, but do you really think that a child born and raised by good people (that is, surrounded by them) will become someone bad? This is just ridiculous! What I agree with is that good people suffer the most. I am a very good person myself and they often stab me in the back. This taught me not to give away my kindness just like that. I'm good, but I'm not unhappy. And the people around me are not bad. In fact, I have good friends, wonderful parents ... and at the same time I know bad people. I think I'm a little contradictory, aren't I? Now let me explain qualitatively - there is no way someone can be surrounded only by bad or only by good people. The character does not depend on the environment. We are this interesting human being. We are a mixture of good and bad. Everyone has both and what he listens to depends on him. right? Now let me explain qualitatively - there is no way someone can be surrounded only by bad or only by good people. The character does not depend on the environment. We are this interesting human being. We are a mixture of good and bad. Everyone has both and what he listens to depends on him. right? Now let me explain qualitatively - there is no way someone can be surrounded only by bad or only by good people. The character does not depend on the environment. We are this interesting human being. We are a mixture of good and bad. Everyone has both and what he listens to depends on him.
Author: I hadn't thought as well as you. I am 13 and a half and I became very interested in the books you wrote about, what others are there and where can I find them?
To the author - here you can find for free the books that interest you - http://chitanka.info/books/category/filosofia I advise you to start with Rousseau, it is not easy to read, but at least you will not live like a blind man. Interesting to read is "Thus Said Zarathustra" A book for everyone and no one Friedrich Nietzsche It is about Eastern philosophies, about Buddhism. If it's too complicated for you, try some of the modern ones - Terry Pratchett is a kind of philosopher, but I admit - I don't like his genre. My favorite book is Orwell's "1984" http://chitanka.info/search?q=1984 In it the author described in the early 20th century. phenomena of modern times that HE HAS NOT WITNESSED - you will know the communist dictatorship here, but also the modern Facebook society, in which everyone knows everything about everyone. There is also a love story, easy to read. I don't think it's too early to start with such literature, now you are shaping yourself as a person and only in this way you will be able to have enough in your head so that you do not become a convenient tool in the hands of some manipulator. If you don't read now, you will regret it later and have the potential to become a "wooden philosopher" - to repeat like a parrot memorized phrases from aunts and grandmothers and who knows - you can become another deluded man who praises various communisms here , dictatorships, murderers and lunatics. The mind, your head are the greatest weapon and capital. There is nothing worse than spiritual poverty and destitution. If you can develop your mind, you will be able to resist anyone who wants to hurt and use you, and you can become a manipulator yourself. Enjoy reading! you will regret it later and have the potential to become a "wooden philosopher" - to repeat like a parrot memorized phrases from aunts and grandmothers and who knows - you can become another deluded man, who here praises various communisms, dictatorships, murderers and abnormalities. The mind, your head are the greatest weapon and capital. There is nothing worse than spiritual poverty and destitution. If you can develop your mind, you will be able to resist anyone who wants to hurt and use you, and you can become a manipulator yourself. Enjoy reading! you will regret it later and have the potential to become a "wooden philosopher" - to repeat like a parrot memorized phrases from aunts and grandmothers and who knows - you can become another deluded man who praises various communisms, dictatorships, murderers and abnormalities. The mind, your head are the greatest weapon and capital. There is nothing worse than spiritual poverty and destitution. If you can develop your mind, you will be able to resist anyone who wants to hurt and use you, and you can become a manipulator yourself. Enjoy reading! There is nothing worse than spiritual poverty and destitution. If you can develop your mind, you will be able to resist anyone who wants to hurt and use you, and you can become a manipulator yourself. Enjoy reading! There is nothing worse than spiritual poverty and destitution. If you can develop your mind, you will be able to resist anyone who wants to hurt and use you, and you can become a manipulator yourself. Enjoy reading!
Look, there are billions of people in the world, and we have been on this earth for thousands of years. And during all this time, a large part of these people who lived in this hole (earthly life) shook their heads to understand what the Almighty had in mind. If you think someone here will give you an answer, um, the chance tends to minus infinity. You think too much, but from personal experience I tell you that you will end up like me with depression, inferiority and only one conclusion - man is an insignificant speck in the whole universe, like every atom in your body. It does not have the potential to understand why you eat, why you go to work, why you sleep, etc. And it will never have it. If you had to know God's plan, you would have his potential, that is, to be equal to him, and this contradicts reality. The fact is, you are human. If you want to be an alien ... the same job. The whole world is governed by laws, there is logic wherever you look, so there is logic to be here. And Kant, Rousseau and the like are not modern at all, to turn to number 1. And it is true that we have free will, but it does not have the power to change some very important things, which we still call destiny. Yes, there is a destiny and the ancients still knew it.
From number 1 - read more and do not speak by heart. Especially read the Bible, there is the foundation of our civilization. There is no destiny. And if the Bible will understand that it is precisely the free role that brings us closer to God, it is our divine quality for which Adam and Eve were kicked out of Heaven. Rousseau and the other philosophers are the next step after the Bible, I recommended this to the Author. Terry Pratchett is our contemporary! Take your pills, they will help you with depression. Philosophy is read because one has interests, not to cure one's illnesses. From experience I tell you - to believe that nothing depends on you, that you are a victim of fate will not bring you anything. Take your destiny in your hands and become a blacksmith of your life - maybe that's why you're here.
From number 5 to 6 - probably your comment is addressed to me. "And if the Bible understands that it is the free role that brings us closer to God" - no one denies it, that's right, but after all we are not gods and therefore some things do not depend on us. "Believing that you are a victim of fate will not bring you anything" - you do not need to believe that you are a VICTIM of fate, but rather you are its child. Fate is destined for you to learn, for your soul to gain experience in earthly life. Otherwise very clear - if you could choose between the difficult and the easy, of course you will choose the easy and you will not learn anything. "to believe that nothing depends on you" - in my comment I said NOTHING, I said some things. It is wrong to think that man has only free will or only destiny. On the contrary - he has a little of both. If, for example, a comet falls to Earth, you with your free will how will you change your destiny to burst? You can not. And finally - the tale that a man forges his own destiny is true insofar as by destiny you mean free will, which is wrong. It means that a person has a certain right to change some things and if he causes something bad to himself through his right to choose, then he really causes it himself. And vice versa - if he brings success, he really won it himself.
There has never been a communist dictatorship. You can skip this book.
8, it is not you who will say whether there was or was not a dictatorship in our country, but history. The UN and Todor Zhivkov himself condemned communism and dictatorship in our country in 1989. Otherwise - invasion of the army of another state killing the whole government and the head of state (prince regent) imposing a government, constitution WITHOUT ELECTIONS rigging elections 50 years = PURE DICTATORSHIP with a dictator PURE DICTATORSHIP communist ideology = pure communism. What is not clear to you? Don't you think we had a communist democracy? Communism and democracy are excluded because the ideology itself presupposes a planned economy and centralized power, which cannot be imposed by a democratic process.
Communism is the only salvation in the world.
Number 10, if the world is the ghetto in which you live, and you are one of the people with small poor souls, whose only goal is to break the bread for the day - yes, communism will save you! Aman from drummers in this country was!
Why do you always distort the topic to political disputes !? He doesn't belong here, there are as many topics as you want, go there to argue! It is a fact that during communism there were dissatisfied people, it is a fact that even now there are dissatisfied people. The world is colorful, people of all kinds, no pleasures.
11, what do you know. You don't know what communism is, that's exactly why I don't argue with you. You can't figure out what it is, even if you search the entire Internet. We eat our bread even now. It's a pity you forgot the overflowing bowls. The guild self-consciousness cannot understand what it is about. you have misconceptions
Number 9? Your comment makes me feel sorry for you, you and others with the thinking imposed by mom and dad. To number 10 - Hardly before people have struggled to bite something that was provided to them, but you're right! Now people want to crunch bread, and while crunching they remember the mid-70s when they could add a leg to the bread (Those who lived at that time remember) Don't you crunch bread now? You don't listen to what your father told you, because they removed the private property from his cafe. ;-) And number 9 do not recommend books in which they write about dictatorships of unimplemented ideas. Communism has never existed in Bulgaria, that's why you become funny by writing with such conviction and pride. You recommend books to the author, but you haven't sat down to read that you need it. :(